Mythadventures game thread: Mythconceptions

[gib]

@@vote grit@@

[higgs2]

gib seems all oer the place to me if you look at the progression of post from yesterday to day. I'm wondering if it's just a shotgun approach to flushing out scum or if it's something else. Does grit always wax philosophical like this? Zig had a point about how irre seems to be contradicting herself, but she tends to do that sometimes, especially when she feels pressured to make a case but doesn't hae one.

[charlou]

Being careful about who's on a possibly smallish scum team and assigning specific roles randomly are not necessarily mutually exclusive principles, depending on just how random we're talking. If a GM wants a good game and a team design or two is small, the GM could both handpick the team(s) and randomise roles on the team(s). I admit it affects whom I finger, and I admit that lynching gifted players is more scummish than townish; but it gives me pause when considering just how players I consider gifted are posting in a game, especially if their post count seems low or vacant of substance.

Now, this ... this is wifom.

[divagreen]

Gib is all over the place, but I just double checked and he was like this on day 1 in the Starfleet game.

Where is Aza?

[divagreen]

I am sorry Feck, but I just reread the thread and you are throwing off some serious scumitude.

You are unusually aggressive, inferred false information and are telling everyone that voting for you as mayor is a "good idea". If you were scum, I would think that you would not be this obvious but maybe you are trying different tactics in order to confuse us.

##vote Feck##

[Zigmen]

I am sorry Feck, but I just reread the thread and you are throwing off some serious scumitude.

You are unusually aggressive, inferred false information and are telling everyone that voting for you as mayor is a "good idea". If you were scum, I would think that you would not be this obvious but maybe you are trying different tactics in order to confuse us.

##vote Feck##

So Scummy, in fact, that I'm convinced Feck is a Jester.

Kudos on your read, Diva.

But, I am not inclined to hand a Jest a Day 1 Victory.

Please vote elsewhere for today and, if you like, vote Feck tomorrow.

[Feck]

I am sorry Feck, but I just reread the thread and you are throwing off some serious scumitude.

You are unusually aggressive, inferred false information and are telling everyone that voting for you as mayor is a "good idea". If you were scum, I would think that you would not be this obvious but maybe you are trying different tactics in order to confuse us.

##vote Feck##

Have you ever got through to day two without saying I'm scummy Diva ? You think I'm scummy if I don't post much, You think I'm scummy if I vote and don't talk , now you are wifoming me as scum because what I've said makes no sense if I'm scum so I must be scum but trying to confuse ? .. Tell me Diva Is it just maybe possible that nothing I could say or not say at any point in the game will ever make you not think I'm scum ?

Let me help you You can't trust me if I view as town ...I must be the don You can't trust me If I vote to lynch Scum ...I must be Bus'ing my team members .
Has it occurred to you that I might not be trying new tactics at all nothing I've done or said is a new 'tactic' I've played the game in similar ways before and must often I'm more outspoken when I'm town .

Zigmen how much do you want to bet ?

What you actually mean is that it's easy to say Feck looks scummy

[Uselesstwit]

I can actually see the feck might be a jester thing. Going after the people checking in, voting dp just like the old feck, mayor voting himself. He does seem to be going out of his way to draw attention to himself on day one.

##unvote feck##

I'd really like to hear more from ksen and anything from aza.

[grit]

gib seems all oer the place to me if you look at the progression of post from yesterday to day. I'm wondering if it's just a shotgun approach to flushing out scum or if it's something else. Does grit always wax philosophical like this? Zig had a point about how irre seems to be contradicting herself, but she tends to do that sometimes, especially when she feels pressured to make a case but doesn't hae one.

Welcome to the game, higgs2.

I agree that the disparity between your posts and gibs seems stark, if only by quantity. I think gib's scum flushing approach is at least similar to last game. That doesn't carry as much weight with me as maybe with some, but I do find it generally beneficial to town. All three of gib, Zig, and irre seem usual thus far to me, but that's not a declaration of townishness, just normalcy.

Neither you or I have placed a lynch vote yet. What's your read so far on DP or ksen?

[grit]

I am sorry Feck, but I just reread the thread and you are throwing off some serious scumitude.

You are unusually aggressive, inferred false information and are telling everyone that voting for you as mayor is a "good idea". If you were scum, I would think that you would not be this obvious but maybe you are trying different tactics in order to confuse us.

##vote Feck##

So Scummy, in fact, that I'm convinced Feck is a Jester.

Kudos on your read, Diva.

But, I am not inclined to hand a Jest a Day 1 Victory.

Please vote elsewhere for today and, if you like, vote Feck tomorrow.

I'm asking myself if Oblivion would put a Jester in a game she's categorised as "minimalistic"? I'm inclined to think not. Am I wrong?

That's not a whiteknight of Feck, just that I think having a Jester in a "minimalistic" game unlikely.

[Mantisdreamz]

I'm not seeing the Feck as jester thing at all

[Mantisdreamz]

define "just checking in."

Ksen, this is kind of strange -- everyone always uses this 'check in' method to bookmark the thread... why ask out of nowhere now?

[divagreen]

I really don't think that Ob would have a jester in a game. She knows how people feel about it and she always tries to deliver good games when she GMs.

But just in case I am wrong...

##unvote Feck##

[Feck]

I'm not seeing the Feck as jester thing at all

But are you seeing me as scum ? Because so far I've been called scummy for acting out of character and for acting 'just like the old Feck ' .

[divagreen]

I think that you are scummy for the reasons that I gave, Feck.