Russian Roulette Game Thread

[Athene]

Athene I will answer Gonzo's question with my vote WHEN I have a better idea who I think is scum i'm not fossing people on too little evidence on day one because Day ones have been Protown posters attacking Protown posters too often . I thought that was clear from my posts ?

Then I strongly suggest you start talking to people and actually participating in the game. We need to get a read on you just as much as you need to get a read on us.

[ksen]

I'm still happy with my vote on zig.

I'd like to put a FOS on diva though for spending a lot of time posting about previous games. That's a good way for scum to be able to look active without actually saying anything.

What do you think of Irretating?

When I first started reading the thread I was suspicious of him(?). But then I got distracted by zig and diva and forgot about Irretating.

[Athene]

Athene I will answer Gonzo's question with my vote WHEN I have a better idea who I think is scum i'm not fossing people on too little evidence on day one because Day ones have been Protown posters attacking Protown posters too often . I thought that was clear from my posts ?

Then I strongly suggest you start talking to people and actually participating in the game. We need to get a read on you just as much as you need to get a read on us.

Also, you weren't asked to vote for somebody, only to discuss who was standing out to you. Surely after 9 pages of chat you should be getting some reads on people.

[Athene]

Feck is not scum hunting at all and has not answered a question put to him by Gonzo.

Zigmen I'm struggling with his early vote on me, and his rationale really. To me it looks like a very flimsy excuse to stick a vote on somebody early on in the game so that he can look like he's participating. I'm aware he normally does default vote me but this time it seems a little different - given the timing of the vote and it being so close to the start of the day and very early in the morning my time. If you are going to pressure vote somebody then you do it if they don't show up when you'd normally expect them to be online.

as I recall he's been lynch-voting you with his first post for several games now. I don't think it has anything to do with whether he thinks you should have been posting by then or not.

True he does do that, as scum or as town. However, in the recent AC game when he and I were discussing strategies he acknowledged that I was at risk for being an early scum kill. How do you get from that to saying that I need to be pressured in to voting otherwise I try and skate through the game?

[Athene]

I'm still happy with my vote on zig.

I'd like to put a FOS on diva though for spending a lot of time posting about previous games. That's a good way for scum to be able to look active without actually saying anything.

What do you think of Irretating?

When I first started reading the thread I was suspicious of him(?). But then I got distracted by zig and diva and forgot about Irretating.

She's a she. I just found it interesting that you called out diva for discussing other games but not Irretating even though she had done exactly the same thing.

[Feck]

@Diva What ? I supported Gonzo in the last game on TR when He was being fossed for spurious reasons and important town clues he had dropped were ignored . and I don't play the Meta And if you read my post when I mayor voted him THIS game you might not be so keen to say I'm supporting him He is one of the few players that has had me almost completely fooled when he was scum , I got it a day before town did ,after I was dead in his first game here (check with OB on that ) THAT is why I mayor voted him.

athena Empty cans rattle the most ! on day one listing the people I think might be scum is seen as good play ? OK FOS fucking everyone Maybe not OB I think I get a good read on her (maybe her scum game is better than I've seen so Yep ) Foss EVERYONE . Or would you like a standard policy fos ?
From the META (love that ) You think I look scummy whatever I post

[oblivion]

@Diva What ? I supported Gonzo in the last game on TR when He was being fossed for spurious reasons and important town clues he had dropped were ignored . and I don't play the Meta And if you read my post when I mayor voted him THIS game you might not be so keen to say I'm supporting him He is one of the few players that has had me almost completely fooled when he was scum , I got it a day before town did ,after I was dead in his first game here (check with OB on that ) THAT is why I mayor voted him.

athena Empty cans rattle the most ! on day one listing the people I think might be scum is seen as good play ? OK FOS fucking everyone Maybe not OB I think I get a good read on her (maybe her scum game is better than I've seen so Yep ) Foss EVERYONE . Or would you like a standard policy fos ?
From the META (love that ) You think I look scummy whatever I post

how do you feel about your mayor choice self-voting?

[Feck]

@Diva What ? I supported Gonzo in the last game on TR when He was being fossed for spurious reasons and important town clues he had dropped were ignored . and I don't play the Meta And if you read my post when I mayor voted him THIS game you might not be so keen to say I'm supporting him He is one of the few players that has had me almost completely fooled when he was scum , I got it a day before town did ,after I was dead in his first game here (check with OB on that ) THAT is why I mayor voted him.

athena Empty cans rattle the most ! on day one listing the people I think might be scum is seen as good play ? OK FOS fucking everyone Maybe not OB I think I get a good read on her (maybe her scum game is better than I've seen so Yep ) Foss EVERYONE . Or would you like a standard policy fos ?
From the META (love that ) You think I look scummy whatever I post

how do you feel about your mayor choice self-voting?

Not good I nearly unvoted !

[Athene]

@Diva What ? I supported Gonzo in the last game on TR when He was being fossed for spurious reasons and important town clues he had dropped were ignored . and I don't play the Meta And if you read my post when I mayor voted him THIS game you might not be so keen to say I'm supporting him He is one of the few players that has had me almost completely fooled when he was scum , I got it a day before town did ,after I was dead in his first game here (check with OB on that ) THAT is why I mayor voted him.

athena Empty cans rattle the most ! on day one listing the people I think might be scum is seen as good play ? OK FOS fucking everyone Maybe not OB I think I get a good read on her (maybe her scum game is better than I've seen so Yep ) Foss EVERYONE . Or would you like a standard policy fos ?
From the META (love that ) You think I look scummy whatever I post

I find that joining in discussions is good play, and answering people when they ask you questions rather then having meltdowns. But that's just me.

[oblivion]

Feck is not scum hunting at all and has not answered a question put to him by Gonzo.

Zigmen I'm struggling with his early vote on me, and his rationale really. To me it looks like a very flimsy excuse to stick a vote on somebody early on in the game so that he can look like he's participating. I'm aware he normally does default vote me but this time it seems a little different - given the timing of the vote and it being so close to the start of the day and very early in the morning my time. If you are going to pressure vote somebody then you do it if they don't show up when you'd normally expect them to be online.

as I recall he's been lynch-voting you with his first post for several games now. I don't think it has anything to do with whether he thinks you should have been posting by then or not.

True he does do that, as scum or as town. However, in the recent AC game when he and I were discussing strategies he acknowledged that I was at risk for being an early scum kill. How do you get from that to saying that I need to be pressured in to voting otherwise I try and skate through the game?

because both are true?

you are a good scumhunter. depending on who else is in the game, you may be protected on night 1. If you aren't scum, you are a good choice for a night 1 kill. And when scum, you tend to keep a low profile.

I agree that he's scummy looking this time out, but I don't think the vote on you was de facto the big hairy tell that you're seeing. It's contextual He came into a thread where interesting stuff was already going on and he did his default day 1 thing.

[oblivion]

^^ may NOT be protected...

[Feck]

Yep ,sorry I'm not good at proactive scum hunting I tend to vote for town specials .

[Athene]

Yep ,sorry I'm not good at proactive scum hunting I tend to vote for town specials .

Heh, I do that too. My crowning achievement is getting a seer lynched on day 1. But you know, he who dares wins, shy bairns don't get no sweets, the early bird gets the worm. You get the idea.

[Zigmen]

I find it interesting that you're only interested in the edit, Zig, making the case that it is somehow more common for scum to break to rule - no matter the change made.

Anything else you find suspicious so far or is that the extent of your scum hunting?

Actually, I provided 3 reasons for my vote on you.

Dunno why some folks are focused on my second reason and I'm even foggier on why you think I had only one reason.

[DennyB]

Vote Gonzo
Seemed to spend alot of time posting if a post belongs in the thread or not.

Vote Mantis
Has a good eye if town.

Not sure what to think of the Irre/Diva exchange but Diva is pinging.
Diva also pings to me when she is town though.

OB seems off. Perhaps it was the wine last night?

Anyone know when Praying is about?

What about Irre? Do you have any opinions on her gameplay so far?

As I said in the post you quoted, I'm not sure about her.