Mythadventures game thread: Mythconceptions

[gib]

@@unvote grit@@

[gib]

My initial inclination on ksen is to put him in my scummish pile. However, he's played in just about every game I've been in to date. My experience has been that when he's scum he usually tries to appear a bit more townish, with more posts, when he's able. He's somewhat of a low poster anyways, but when he's mostly absent it's usually because he's either vanilla town or a specialed scum.

my bold gritty boy - this reminds me of bilirubin in the last game, remember that?

[Uselesstwit]

What do people make of irre so far this game? her post count is really low for a long day, and her interaction with mantis seems off to me.

[Feck]

My initial inclination on ksen is to put him in my scummish pile. However, he's played in just about every game I've been in to date. My experience has been that when he's scum he usually tries to appear a bit more townish, with more posts, when he's able. He's somewhat of a low poster anyways, but when he's mostly absent it's usually because he's either vanilla town or a specialed scum.

my bold gritty boy - this reminds me of bilirubin in the last game, remember that?

you think Grit is scum or Ksen ?

[gib]

My initial inclination on ksen is to put him in my scummish pile. However, he's played in just about every game I've been in to date. My experience has been that when he's scum he usually tries to appear a bit more townish, with more posts, when he's able. He's somewhat of a low poster anyways, but when he's mostly absent it's usually because he's either vanilla town or a specialed scum.

my bold gritty boy - this reminds me of bilirubin in the last game, remember that?

you think Grit is scum or Ksen ?

in the last game bili specified that he had so and so down as 'vanilla town' and someone picked him up on it - ie why would town specify vanilla as that only helps scum. Bili admitted it was a slip and amazingly we all let him off - he was scum and won

[Feck]

Oh ok and btw ## unvote ###

[Mantisdreamz]

UT and feck, you've convinced me.

##unvote feck##

##vote zigmen##

I'm not sure about this. I don't agree with zigmen's theory about lynching feck tomorrow, but I really don't see zig as scum either. What it comes down to for me is that if we think feck is a jester we shouldn't lynch him, if we don't think there is a jester this game we should lynch him today. Zigmen wanting to consider him the jester AND lynch him tomorrow is poorly thought out, but doesn't necessarily make zigmen scum.

my thoughts exactly

unvote
vote ksen

[Mantisdreamz]

What do people make of irre so far this game? her post count is really low for a long day, and her interaction with mantis seems off to me.

Not sure.. I'm wary of her, more so than others

[grit]

My initial inclination on ksen is to put him in my scummish pile. However, he's played in just about every game I've been in to date. My experience has been that when he's scum he usually tries to appear a bit more townish, with more posts, when he's able. He's somewhat of a low poster anyways, but when he's mostly absent it's usually because he's either vanilla town or a specialed scum.

my bold gritty boy - this reminds me of bilirubin in the last game, remember that?

I'm not saying ksen is vanilla town, I'm saying he hasn't seemed to play when he is, in games we've both been in; as though when there isn't a game incentive of a special role he somewhat passes on the game. In the TR Kingmaker game where he was vanilla town he barely showed up at all, and he's done the same at OL/CAC. But he's also laid low beyond his usual low posting in games where he was a specialed scum. He's posted a bit more since then, so the point may be moot. At the time I think ksen maybe had 2 posts in the game.

[grit]

in the last game bili specified that he had so and so down as 'vanilla town' and someone picked him up on it - ie why would town specify vanilla as that only helps scum. Bili admitted it was a slip and amazingly we all let him off - he was scum and won

In this game a few players have already claimed "town", which if my game flavour analysis is correct may also be helping to scum, if these players are thought trustworthy on that point. Hopefully I'm wrong.

[grit]

I did a bit of stalking. Am I correct in thinking Azathoth hasn't been online since before the game started? So his role PM may not have been read and his absence isn't just some post restriction thing?

[Mantisdreamz]

I did a bit of stalking. Am I correct in thinking Azathoth hasn't been online since before the game started? So his role PM may not have been read and his absence isn't just some post restriction thing?

he usually shows up pretty late

[Feck]

Aza last visited, Mon Jun 20, 2011 2:25 pm

[ksen]

UT and feck, you've convinced me.

##unvote feck##

##vote zigmen##

I'm not sure about this. I don't agree with zigmen's theory about lynching feck tomorrow, but I really don't see zig as scum either. What it comes down to for me is that if we think feck is a jester we shouldn't lynch him, if we don't think there is a jester this game we should lynch him today. Zigmen wanting to consider him the jester AND lynch him tomorrow is poorly thought out, but doesn't necessarily make zigmen scum.

my thoughts exactly

unvote
vote ksen

[ksen]

in the last game bili specified that he had so and so down as 'vanilla town' and someone picked him up on it - ie why would town specify vanilla as that only helps scum. Bili admitted it was a slip and amazingly we all let him off - he was scum and won

i picked him up on that and i was his scumbuddy . . . just sayin'.