Russian Roulette Game Thread

[Gonzo]

Does anyone know if a Town Bomb can kill a Seer?

[Gonzo]

I'm wondering if scum knew in advance about some town members being bombs.

That would entirely defreat the purpose of having Town Bombs. That a weird statement, Athene, and one I don't think a townie would make. Can you see how this could appear to be WIFOM set out by scum? Do you agree scum knowing would defeat the purpose of a Bomb?

[Athene]

I'm wondering if scum knew in advance about some town members being bombs.

That would entirely defreat the purpose of having Town Bombs. That a weird statement, Athene, and one I don't think a townie would make. Can you see how this could appear to be WIFOM set out by scum? Do you agree scum knowing would defeat the purpose of a Bomb?

Perhaps in a regular game but we're playing one called Russian Roulette and so far there have been two town bombs. I'm not going to assume that a normal vanilla mafia setup applies.

[Gonzo]

How would it make since in the game mechanics for the scum to know who are bombs, though? Scum want to avoid Bombs, so obviously they will not be clued in on who they are. Rather, like specials, they will hunt for they and recalibrate their choice of actions accordingly. You seem to be special-hunting as long as you maintain the opinion scum would know who the Bombs are. Now do you see why I would think that, or would you argue my point?

[Gonzo]

*sense >_<

[Athene]

Also, mantis unvoted diva because of this post.

I never said that Irre voted for me because she had a grudge against me.

I made a joke at the beginning and I have stated this several times. I trust Gonzo more than you right now.

Mantis get your vote off of me right now.

Adenosine, you go ahead and vote for me. I don't know you.

I read this and thought it was just diva dicking around but mantis read something in it that convinced her she needed to take her vote off diva straight away.

[Gonzo]

Which seems perfectly reasonable, given the game set-up, in my opinion. You are mislead or you are scum, Athene.

[Gonzo]

Say, if Diva knew she was a Bomb - and the scum ALSO knew she was a Bomb - who would it benefit and why?

It's a trick question, also rhetorical, so don't bother. See? Scum can't know who the Bombs are.

[Gonzo]

Not going to concede to the point, Athene? Okay. Think it over some and get back to me. vote Athene for now.

[Athene]

How would it make since in the game mechanics for the scum to know who are bombs, though? Scum want to avoid Bombs, so obviously they will not be clued in on who they are. Rather, like specials, they will hunt for they and recalibrate their choice of actions accordingly. You seem to be special-hunting as long as you maintain the opinion scum would know who the Bombs are. Now do you see why I would think that, or would you argue my point?

Not who the bombs are, just that there are bombs. I got the idea because of something Mantis said which made me think maybe she had knowledge not available to the rest of us.

[Gonzo]

How would it make since in the game mechanics for the scum to know who are bombs, though? Scum want to avoid Bombs, so obviously they will not be clued in on who they are. Rather, like specials, they will hunt for they and recalibrate their choice of actions accordingly. You seem to be special-hunting as long as you maintain the opinion scum would know who the Bombs are. Now do you see why I would think that, or would you argue my point?

Not who the bombs are, just that there are bombs. I got the idea because of something Mantis said which made me think maybe she had knowledge not available to the rest of us.

Which could mean one of two things. Do you see that? Mantis, I agree, has shown he knows something more than us. That alone is bot incriminating, though, which is why you shouldn't vote for her for that alone. We need to hear more from Matis first.

[Gonzo]

*is not

[Athene]

How would it make since in the game mechanics for the scum to know who are bombs, though? Scum want to avoid Bombs, so obviously they will not be clued in on who they are. Rather, like specials, they will hunt for they and recalibrate their choice of actions accordingly. You seem to be special-hunting as long as you maintain the opinion scum would know who the Bombs are. Now do you see why I would think that, or would you argue my point?

Not who the bombs are, just that there are bombs. I got the idea because of something Mantis said which made me think maybe she had knowledge not available to the rest of us.

Which could mean one of two things. Do you see that? Mantis, I agree, has shown he knows something more than us. That alone is bot incriminating, though, which is why you shouldn't vote for her for that alone. We need to hear more from Matis first.

Gonzo

[Gonzo]

No, Athene.

Do I have to scream it? For fuck's sake!

[Gonzo]

Wait for Mantis to clear things up for us. I think we should remain at a stalemate for now, and I will explain myself when Mantis explains WHY she knew Diva was hinting. When Matis makes that statement, we can judge better if she is lying or not. Until then, there is more than one reason Mantis could have known a hint was dropped.