MGS3: Snake Eater Mafia - Tactical Espionage Action (GAME)

[charlou]

Can somebody explain to me what the peanut gallery is? That's a mechanic that hasn't existed in mafia games I've played on other forums.

Rereading the thread ... does this question ping for anyone else? Isn't "peanut gallery" self explanatory and commonly understood?

Also, two people replied to the question, but there was no acknowledgement of those replies from you, Andrew, kinda making the question seem like you were asking for the sake of something to say?


crosspost MZ and amok

[charlou]

xCharlou wrote:http://www.google.ca/#sclient=psy-ab&hl ... 88&bih=504
Are you the traitor?

My role doesn't mention traitor. But as I said, in reading the (video) game description, there are all kinds of traitors/defectors in play, on both sides.

Good grief, what a mess.

It doesn't seem like a mess to me ... Unless you mean your quoting there

Re the traitor concern, let's ask MZ ... MZ was it your impression from reading the role PM that it was flavour, or an actual role?

[Magicziggy]

Clearly role. The character fitted perfectly when I read the wiki.

[amok]

My quote attempt was definitely messed up. I was posting about Occupy Nova Scotia on another board, and must have had the URL stuck in my "Control V." Sorry.

[charlou]

No need to be sorry .. I was just teasing about that.

[irretating]

Can somebody explain to me what the peanut gallery is? That's a mechanic that hasn't existed in mafia games I've played on other forums.

Rereading the thread ... does this question ping for anyone else? Isn't "peanut gallery" self explanatory and commonly understood?

Also, two people replied to the question, but there was no acknowledgement of those replies from you, Andrew, kinda making the question seem like you were asking for the sake of something to say?


crosspost MZ and amok

Yes, Andrew has registered as a person of interest, for sure. Jokey lynch vote, then followy mayor vote, all very careful. The PG question didn't ping, though.

[charlou]

Can somebody explain to me what the peanut gallery is? That's a mechanic that hasn't existed in mafia games I've played on other forums.

Rereading the thread ... does this question ping for anyone else? Isn't "peanut gallery" self explanatory and commonly understood?

Also, two people replied to the question, but there was no acknowledgement of those replies from you, Andrew, kinda making the question seem like you were asking for the sake of something to say?


crosspost MZ and amok

Yes, Andrew has registered as a person of interest, for sure. Jokey lynch vote, then followy mayor vote, all very careful. The PG question didn't ping, though.

Do you think a jokey lynch vote is 'very careful'?

[irretating]

Yes, I think it could be.

Or, I could be wrong. He's an unknown quantity. I already posted, asking him about his posts. What he's not, though, is a n00b.

[charlou]

Just new to the culture, as you said.

[Drewish]

Andrew: you're a complete unknown quantity for us, but we know that you know how to play mafia. Do you think your jokey lynch vote and then the 'oh yes good point MZ' mayor vote would make you look suspicious to your fellow mafians elsewhere?

People are always suspicious of me because of my abrasive personality

Andrewclunn

What do you make of the play so far? Anyone standing out to you?
You seem relaxed for your first game here.

You've asked a couple of questions and cracked a couple of quips.
What do you make of my answer about role claiming?

Seems like a foolish practice to me. By not having an accepted standard 'town' behavior for day 1, you can't really judge people's activity except on an individual basis, which just leads to paranoid speculation and wifom. Seems like a very pro-scum culture here.

Can somebody explain to me what the peanut gallery is? That's a mechanic that hasn't existed in mafia games I've played on other forums.

Rereading the thread ... does this question ping for anyone else? Isn't "peanut gallery" self explanatory and commonly understood?

Also, two people replied to the question, but there was no acknowledgement of those replies from you, Andrew, kinda making the question seem like you were asking for the sake of something to say?


crosspost MZ and amok

Yes, Andrew has registered as a person of interest, for sure. Jokey lynch vote, then followy mayor vote, all very careful. The PG question didn't ping, though.

Do you think a jokey lynch vote is 'very careful'?

Case and point.

[charlou]

Andrew: you're a complete unknown quantity for us, but we know that you know how to play mafia. Do you think your jokey lynch vote and then the 'oh yes good point MZ' mayor vote would make you look suspicious to your fellow mafians elsewhere?

People are always suspicious of me because of my abrasive personality

Andrewclunn

What do you make of the play so far? Anyone standing out to you?
You seem relaxed for your first game here.

You've asked a couple of questions and cracked a couple of quips.
What do you make of my answer about role claiming?

Seems like a foolish practice to me. By not having an accepted standard 'town' behavior for day 1, you can't really judge people's activity except on an individual basis, which just leads to paranoid speculation and wifom. Seems like a very pro-scum culture here.

What is foolish? Not role claiming on day one?

Can somebody explain to me what the peanut gallery is? That's a mechanic that hasn't existed in mafia games I've played on other forums.

Rereading the thread ... does this question ping for anyone else? Isn't "peanut gallery" self explanatory and commonly understood?

Also, two people replied to the question, but there was no acknowledgement of those replies from you, Andrew, kinda making the question seem like you were asking for the sake of something to say?


crosspost MZ and amok

Yes, Andrew has registered as a person of interest, for sure. Jokey lynch vote, then followy mayor vote, all very careful. The PG question didn't ping, though.

Do you think a jokey lynch vote is 'very careful'?

Case and point.

I don't see how these two even correlate, let alone the latter being an example.

Abrasiveness aside (I didn't even notice it), can you clarify what you're getting at here, please.

[Drewish]

Just that you all are barking up trees. With no night results and no RCing or PCing going on, there's no way to trip up scum. This is the pre-game show. The real fun starts Night 1

[charlou]

The real fun starts Night 1

Sure, if you're scum.

Day one posts can furnish information that is important as the game progresses.

[Drewish]

Well then why not get some tangible information? How about a pRC of people's genders? That shouldn't reveal too much. Plenty of male and female characters, but it would restrict scum for fake claims later.

[charlou]

Well then why not get some tangible information? How about a pRC of people's genders? That shouldn't reveal too much. Plenty of male and female characters, but it would restrict scum for fake claims later.

If scum have safe claims it's useless.