Darkover Mafia Game Thread

[def]

Since you paraphrased it, I assume you found a rule which said no verbatim quotes. Could you provide the link ASAP, please, because I provided a quote as did Feck before, and I think we may have breached the rules. I'd just like to check.

I know you're on a Sherlock Holmes high right now, but I really respect you as a player so I'll leave the taunts to a minimum. You honestly think you're catching me doing something.

So, here:
http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 14#p846814
Do not post your role PM or other GM communication. It's ok to paraphrase your role PM in the game thread.

[CookieJon]

Do us a favor and gloat more...

(Haha. Yes I am a bit! Sorry, I'm a bit tipsy!)

... so you'll look all the sillier when my role is revealed.

Well that will be your reward for this terrible injustice. I can live with that.

[ksen]

vote def

Simple answer is that you are lying.

[def]

vote def

Simple answer is that you are lying.

Simpler answer is that the game host made a mistake. People should hold off their vote at least until Oblivion reads my PM request to confirm (or not) that she changed my role parameters on day two.

[Linus]

I count 3 dead town specials and 6 special claims from players still in the game. I find it hard to believe that all of them are town. With the block and the fact that Charlou already claimed a protection-type role...

vote def

[CookieJon]

It's also worth noting that Feck's watcher reports have always come AFTER everyone else knew the facts anyway, and the one time someone explicitly withholds information before Feck's report may be able to be discredited... he forgot to send in his action!

I don't know what that means, but there it is.

[Feck]

Yep I suck (but I got good and drunk had a great time shouting obscenities at Xians ) I 've been thinking A doc would over- load the team we have lots of roles but some are only one night things

with reservations I'll Vote Def

[DennyB]

Def's whiteknighting threads of bolero.

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 20#p851963

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 20#p852014

sort on here too..

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 60#p852474

Vote Def

[def]

Don't know what whiteknighting is.

About Bolero, I never stuck up for her once, I just was asking to see what was making her scummy to you people. Informed voting, you know?

Overall thoughts?
It's pretty lame when you get voted for for simply for being 100% honest. Go for it, vote me out, then reread my posts and see you're wrong. Don't take offense if I call you all dummies tomorrow, I do that every time I get wrongly voted out.

For the record, this will be the third game this year I lost a game in part because of inconsistency from the host. I've hosted once, and know it's a juggling act, plus I know how irritating player bitching is, so I won't harp on about it. Sorry.

[Feck]

Def stop crying, I've been nothing but honest and nobody believes Me EVAH !

[def]

By the way, Oblivion has read my PM and is making a judgment on it now, I'm guessing.

[oblivion]

I won't be able to confirm or deny regarding game-related PMs.

[def]

Fair enough.

Have fun you guys

[DennyB]

Don't know what whiteknighting is.

About Bolero, I never stuck up for her once, I just was asking to see what was making her scummy to you people. Informed voting, you know?

Overall thoughts?
It's pretty lame when you get voted for for simply for being 100% honest. Go for it, vote me out, then reread my posts and see you're wrong. Don't take offense if I call you all dummies tomorrow, I do that every time I get wrongly voted out.

For the record, this will be the third game this year I lost a game in part because of inconsistency from the host. I've hosted once, and know it's a juggling act, plus I know how irritating player bitching is, so I won't harp on about it. Sorry.

my bold above
Def,
If you do flip town (and I don't think you will) then you win with town. Being lynched does not mean you lose as you should know.
Frankly I think this is a brillant ruse.

[praying]

I do not buy for one minute that raven made a mistake in a key role like doctor. She is an experienced GM, I see her maybe making a mistake in the vote count but not in a town special role, and a role that is so common.