Venture Bros: day 2

Post by **Mantisdreamz** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:45 am

Magicziggy wrote:
Mantisdreamz wrote:
Magicziggy wrote:Why are we not lynching amok? It's the one we all agree on?
do you think she is more scummy than aza or gonzo?
I can't judge scumminess from little or no input.

With that, why are you happy lynching Gonzo?

Post by **Gonzo** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:50 am

irretating wrote:Hmm guys, look at gonzo more closely. I'd put him as scum, too. Jokey but careful not to commit to anything (in fact a nice smooth white knight on MZ.) Oh and remember DP pointed out that as scum gonzo talks about his scum buddies? Have a look at his interaction with mantis.

Hi, irre. I think MZ is town because his story makes sense to me. I am the other role blocker. I also tried to block mantis and think she is possible scum and should be lynched today, but I did not send my PM in time. I don't think I will be a very effective special, so might as well clear MZ now.

vote mantis

Post by **Gonzo** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:53 am

btw my reasoning for mantis being scum is mostly because aza said she should be grilled today before he was lynched, and he is better at this game than I am. XD

Post by **Gonzo** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:53 am

need to catch up on reading, too.

Post by **amok** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:54 am

You know, it's not a bad option this early in the game, unless someone has a real strong feeling about someone being Scum.

I came in with a bad attitude (feeling sorry for myself about a game that ended just hours before this one started), determined to play differently (no hours spent reading and re-reading and making notes), and now I sit here looking like a suspicious jerk and not having any solid ideas.

One thing that did strike me (no matter what you guys decide about me), is that I really can't see how Charlou/Aza could have been Scum. Even needing to get out of the game for whatever reason, I figure a Scum player would have dropped a vote somewhere. Maybe even on a team member who wasn't in any serious danger, but certainly at least on a Town who was under heat. It would only have taken latching on to someone else's reasoning, and rewriting it a bit.

Post by **Gonzo** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:58 am

charlou also outed from the Mario Party game before started. I wonder if something is up with her, and don't want to read into it too much as it would be unfair to her and Aza and Linus, but I could see her subbing out as scum more than I could see her doing that as town. She could have just told us she'd be away for awhile or whatever, whereas as scum she has more of an obligation to play actively.

Again, it's not really game play... so what's more important is what she has posted.

Post by **Magicziggy** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:04 am

##unvote amok##
##vote mantis##

Makes sense

Post by **Mantisdreamz** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:06 am

amok wrote:One thing that did strike me (no matter what you guys decide about me), is that I really can't see how Charlou/Aza could have been Scum. Even needing to get out of the game for whatever reason, I figure a Scum player would have dropped a vote somewhere. Maybe even on a team member who wasn't in any serious danger, but certainly at least on a Town who was under heat. It would only have taken latching on to someone else's reasoning, and rewriting it a bit.

That's also why I had her as town yesterday. But I don't get Aza's takeover and not saying much.

Post by **Mantisdreamz** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:07 am

Magicziggy wrote:##unvote amok##
##vote mantis##

Makes sense

Post by **amok** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:09 am

My problem at this stage is, I was pretty sure gib was Scum yesterday, but not so much today. I can't believe either Matt or MZ are Scum, because it really does make sense that there would be (at least) two Hanks. One of the reasons I was on gib, besides his suspicion of Irre for what I didn't see as a legitimate reason, was that I thought he was being unreasonable about MZ misunderstanding what Matt was suggesting about lynching both of them. Not really a good idea, in my opinion, but not Scummy. And not Scummy to misunderstand his reasoning, either. I've read that exchange over a few times, now, and I see where MZ was coming from.

So I'm left having too many people in my Town pile, and the leftovers are just on the fringe.

Post by **Magicziggy** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:10 am

Charlou did vote yesterday

Post by **Magicziggy** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:13 am

##unvote mantis##
That was too hasty to be honest.
I shouldn't trust the judgement of some who has read the thread.

Post by **Magicziggy** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:13 am

Hasn't

Post by **Mantisdreamz** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:18 am

Gonzo, I'm not sure i understand you

Amok - I read it as both of them being confused. MZ seems town more so than Matt... but i don't think Matt is scum.

Post by **amok** » Fri Dec 02, 2011 7:18 am

Magicziggy wrote:Charlou did vote yesterday

I know she did. It was a good, solid Town vote, done in the end rush. I was talking about her first post where she said she wouldn't.

rationalia.com