ElfQuest Mafia - Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

Athene was first to vote diva and she made a good point. Not voting is not pro-town.

Aza switched to diva from Athene for no real reason.

Zigmen then voted her for hiding her mafia experience.

MZ, I can see why Athene would vote diva based on diva not voting, but you being a ratskept mafia regular know very well that there is a meme about it not being a good idea to lynch anyone on day 1. In fact, that's why there is the compulsory voting rule there lately.

Yes. I know. But doesn't stop Athene's reason being valid.

[Uselesstwit]

I agree, athene's vote really doesn't bother me as much as the other two. Especially aza going from athene's bw to following athene onto a bw. I'd really like to hear a rational for that.

[Magicziggy]

I don't think the restriction has affected you at all actually.
And you do make a very good point. It's something new players have to learn about the need to influence thinking by voting when town. And obviously scum do it because they want to look townish and get town players lynched.

Hmm.. I do think she's scummy. But wouldn't a team have reigned her in and suggested she vote? Not sure.
I'm leaning Gonzo on a re-read. His play last game was confident and informed. He was the Don. This is the complete opposite. One drive by vote. I'll wait and see if he shows.

This was my response to Athene's vote. My comment about her being scummy is something she objected to. Her behaviour is scummy and we have to make allowances for her to find it as naive town.

[Feck]

That post has been changed since last night. It didn't say vanilla before.

I didn't think I would have missed that .... a vanilla Troll would have made me laugh .

[Uselesstwit]

When's daybreak?

[Magicziggy]

50 mins till daybreak

[Uselesstwit]

ah, i see, i need to take the timestamp off of daylight saving time.

[Athene]

Athene was first to vote diva and she made a good point. Not voting is not pro-town.

Aza switched to diva from Athene for no real reason.

Zigmen then voted her for hiding her mafia experience.

MZ, I can see why Athene would vote diva based on diva not voting, but you being a ratskept mafia regular know very well that there is a meme about it not being a good idea to lynch anyone on day 1. In fact, that's why there is the compulsory voting rule there lately.

I'm kind of curious why you feel the need to make this point. What MZ knows about the game play at ratskept has absolutely no bearing on my vote rationale.

[irretating]

That is true, Athene, but my point was about MZ saying Diva was not being pro-town, when on ratskept mafia it would be seen as pro-town (bizarre as that is). You were not to know that, but MZ did.

[Uselesstwit]

so irre, who worries you the most?

[irretating]

Aza. He normally doesn't put down such an easy vote. Plus he's not said much. I see MZ perhaps being a little too chummy with everyone and that makes me nervous. Linus is pinging me a bit but I don't have a feel for his game, I've not seen him play scum. Zigmen is all over the place, and deserved my vote for spraying votes around and being inconsistent.

I want to hear more from charlou today.

[MSG]

I agree, athene's vote really doesn't bother me as much as the other two. Especially aza going from athene's bw to following athene onto a bw. I'd really like to hear a rational for that.

Aza actually started on diva, switched to athene, then switched back to diva. If that's not scummy it's pretty weird.

[Linus]

Mantisdreamz, who are you most suspicious of?

[irretating]

UT and Linus, who worries you most?

[Linus]

UT and Linus, who worries you most?

See previous post:

I have MSG and MZ as partly clear by today's vote sequence & lynch. Divagreen mostly looks like n00b town to me, the "mock indignation" comment is weird, though. I'm still thinking about what to make of Athene as well as UT's and MZ's comments about the posting restriction. Zigmen looks a bit scummy based on the content of his posts, praying looks scummy based on the lack of content of her posts. A bunch of players are worrying because of low participation.