Darkover Mafia Game Thread

[DennyB]

1. Ani– vanilla town
2. Feck - claims watcher
3.Divagreen - scum kidnapper
4. Mantisdreamz - cleared by denny with SK gone??
5. Adenosine– indie, sole survivor
6. Azathoth– town mason
7. Zigmen- Innocent Child
8. Athene- town mason
9. Ksen – double voter, kidnapped N1
10. UselessTwit– Scum Don
11. Bolero- scum role-blocker
12. CookieJon - claims role blocker
13 Charlou - claims 1-shot bodyguard
14. DennyB - claims 1-shot lie detector
15. Linus
16. Def – claims Doc/protector
17. Praying

[def]

That's an interesting two names that have no claim going on there...

[DennyB]

I guessing 5 scum plus the indy this game. That means 2 scum left.
Not sure how a traitor would figure into the mix.
I wonder what other effects the kidnaping had if any?

I'm willing to let Def go another day but odds are we should lynch scum if he is town.

[DennyB]

unvote
Vote Linus

[DennyB]

oops
unvote
Vote Linus

[DennyB]

Also if there is a traitor and they know the scum are, then i think Mantis' statement of "I am not quite sure if Bolero is scum or not" which was confirmed true would also clear her of that too.

[charlou]

def, where do you usually play mafia ... and how often have you played?

I've played with you on RatSkep I've played almost every game there since Masquerade.
And I started playing on a LEGO forum, of all places. The details of the rules are the same, but the discretion of the host puts a lot of things up in the air.

The winning with town thing ... my impression the few games I played at RatSkep, was that if town wins, all the players on the town team, living or dead have won with town. Can you explain why you don't think that's the case? (Are you def there?)

[ksen]

Hmmm, I'm inclined to get rid of linus and praying first since they haven't been "cleared" yet. After that we start hashing out the ones that have been provisionally cleared.

unvote

vote linus

[DennyB]

Hmmm, I'm inclined to get rid of linus and praying first since they haven't been "cleared" yet. After that we start hashing out the ones that have been provisionally cleared.

unvote

vote linus

I agree with this

[DennyB]

Praying,
Would you care to vote for Linus?

[def]

The winning with town thing ... my impression the few games I played at RatSkep, was that if town wins, all the players on the town team, living or dead have won with town. Can you explain why you don't think that's the case? (Are you def there?)

Yeah, I'm def there.

I'm looking through the games there now, and you're right, the few I looked at were team wins. I guess I never paid much attention to the details. Survivors get credit there (ie.http://www.rationalskepticism.org/fun-g ... ml#p636852), so I was just looking at them as the winners, though they distinguish between winners and survivors. The other site I use, and have hosted at, only counts survivors, not team wins (my game, by the way, http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.p ... opic=50248)

Sorry for the confusion, I was just mixing up the terms winners and survivors.

[charlou]

The winning with town thing ... my impression the few games I played at RatSkep, was that if town wins, all the players on the town team, living or dead have won with town. Can you explain why you don't think that's the case? (Are you def there?)

Yeah, I'm def there.

I'm looking through the games there now, and you're right, the few I looked at were team wins. I guess I never paid much attention to the details. Survivors get credit there (ie.http://www.rationalskepticism.org/fun-g ... ml#p636852), so I was just looking at them as the winners, though they distinguish between winners and survivors. The other site I use, and have hosted at, only counts survivors, not team wins (my game, by the way, http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.p ... opic=50248)

Sorry for the confusion, I was just mixing up the terms winners and survivors.

No worries. I wondered if that were the case, hence my question.

[charlou]

Also if there is a traitor and they know the scum are, then i think Mantis' statement of "I am not quite sure if Bolero is scum or not" which was confirmed true would also clear her of that too.

I don't know if there's a traitor, but, if we do accept cookie blocked def, and def's claim about his dream and being a doc, what other explanation might there be for no nightkill? It could be that scum simply neglected to put their night action in, perhaps for the same reason Feck gave ... I don't think that's the case, but it's possible.


Anyone else been having ideas about various scenarios that may or may not amount to wifom if voiced? I'm going to go along with the occam's razor approach and vote linus ... we can consider scenarios tomorrow if he flips town.

[praying]

not that this clears me but

I am Ellemir Lanart-Alton and I win when there is no danger to town


vote linus

[charlou]

I win when there is no danger to town

Are those the words used in your role pm?