Tarot III Mafia: Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

As much as I hate profile watching .... aza has been online since the game started .

That way lies madness.

I've said it as scum and as town.

Profile watching will lead us to lynch for completely the wrong reasons.
I was online for many hours yesterday and paid little attention to this thread as it wasn't moving.

I mostly agree with you, but in this case I consider it worthy of comment because he hasn't so much as checked in.

Noted. We can ask him about that.

[charlou]

You seem uncharacteristically nervous and overly defensive over a simple question, Amok.

##vote ksen##

##vote Amok##

[amok]

You seem uncharacteristically nervous and overly defensive over a simple question, Amok.

##vote ksen##

##vote Amok##

I don't think so (though I'll grant that only I can know where I'm coming from). Nervousness/defensiveness wasn't an issue. It was that question from Athene, that made no sense at all considering what I had said and done, that raised my hackles.

[charlou]

CHarlou often doesn't play much on day one whether town or scum. She's not a good day 1 lynch imo.
Gonzo is. Last game he should have gone early but managed to wriggle and squirm and survived till the end.

MZ, do you already think Gonzo is scum this game?

[charlou]

Athene, what do you think about that post of MZ's that I just quoted? Amok, your thoughts, too.

[amok]

Charlou, why did you lynch vote Ksen?

Athene, why did you ask if I'd Mayor vote DP, based on the "gambler's fallacy," when I had just voted for you, and also explained it had been "just a thought"?

[charlou]

Charlou, why did you lynch vote Ksen?

I lynch voted ksen because MZ mayor voted him straight out of the gate. I wanted to see both their reactions. I don't usually mayor vote to encourage a seer view, but I decided to mayor vote MZ for that reason today.

[amok]

Athene, what do you think about that post of MZ's that I just quoted? Amok, your thoughts, too.

I'm a bit lost on that, to be honest. I haven't played enough games with various people to have a solid grasp of how they play, one way or another. I fall back on to stuff said in the particular game being played.

[oblivion]

Mayor
athene - 2
mz - 2
athene - 1
ksen - 1
aza - 1

Lynch
gonzo - 2
dp - 1
amok - 1
ksen - 1

nightfall is in 4 hours 8 minutes.

[amok]

Charlou, why did you lynch vote Ksen?

I lynch voted ksen because MZ mayor voted him straight out of the gate. I wanted to see both their reactions. I don't usually mayor vote to encourage a seer view, but I decided to mayor vote MZ for that reason today.

Wow. That makes sense. That's quite interesting and very clever. I'm going back to read individual responses.

[Magicziggy]

CHarlou often doesn't play much on day one whether town or scum. She's not a good day 1 lynch imo.
Gonzo is. Last game he should have gone early but managed to wriggle and squirm and survived till the end.

MZ, do you already think Gonzo is scum this game?

There is no clear reason to believe anyone is scum at the moment.
Gonzo included.

[Athene]

Athene, I'm struggling here, as I assume many of us do on Day One, but I'll ask why you asked me if I'd Mayor vote DP based on that gamblers' fallacy thing, when (in my opinion) I posted that it had simply crossed my mind, and I moved on. It's not like there are a gazillion posts on this thread, to confuse issues and posts.

I'm not confused. I knew what I was asking and to whom. I asked you to engage you in discussion over a post which stood out to me.

[Gonzo]

##vote ksen##

MZ why should ksen be mayor?

To get people talking of course. And to get ksen in the game. He's not exactly a prolific poster. People should talk about him.

Why lynch him? That question goed to Charlou as well.

Your mayor vote was suspicious because you gave no reasoning. The same is true for charlou's mayor vote for you (MZ), Zig's mayor vote for UT, and Feck's mayor vote for Aza.

Not to mention lynch votes and what I haven't read yet.

[Gonzo]

##unvote ksen##

[Magicziggy]

At the start of the game there is no reason to vote.
If I gave a reason other than to get people talking it would be bullshit.